BRISTOL, R.I. __ The voices of Roger Williams University students raised in dispute and agreement with author, Nicholas Carr during his visit Monday. His acclaimed novels, New York Times bestseller “The Shallows: What the Internet is Doing to Our Brains,” and his recent work “The Glass Cage: Automation and Us” both take a critical look at the way technology has shifted human behavior and capabilities.
“More and more, we allow the gadget to choose what we think about and how we think,” Carr said.
This is a side effect that Carr points out is a factor for individuals of all income levels. The prominence of technologies in households is consistent regardless of whether or not the family can afford to eat.
He points out that any innovation, whether recent, or long ago, has an impact on the human way of life. Especially with the rise of smart technologies that constantly engage its users, Carr noticed a strong shift in attention span and focus ability.
“I was having trouble tuning out and exercising my ability to focus,” he said.
Carr has dedicated his career to bring awareness to this concept which he sees as an increasing issue of society. He explains that the Internet is a great resource as an information-rich environment but that it also creates an interruption-rich environment that has forced the brain to constantly shift focus. Instead of retaining long term knowledge, it has grown common to simply scan for multiple answers and instant stimulus that ultimately cause cognitive overload and never reach long term memory.
Many RWU students disputed this point, saying that the Internet is a constant aid that provides more information than is imaginable with a press of a button.
“We can’t train ourselves to retain information without paying attention to it,” Carr said. “I think you’re wrong if you think that there’s nothing lost with more adaptations. Adaptations can make us shallow thinkers.”
He explained the trade-off that comes with constant reliance on innovation. He argues that adapting to the ability to shift focus easier means that we lose out on the value of what comes from retaining information. The tools that function to make tasks easier come with the cost of weakening mindful knowledge, critical thinking, imagination and reflection.
“It is the act of deep thought that is valuable, but the net discourages this,” said Carr. “We lose the control of our own thoughts and the control of our own working minds.”